The difference between glory and heartbreak came down to a single shot in what became an unforgettable high school basketball showdown. OLSM’s thrilling 54-53 win over Toledo St. John Jesuit had the packed gymnasium in a frenzy. Spectators seemed to have the Michigan – Ohio State football game fresh on their minds. Fans stayed glued to their seats until the final buzzer echoed through the arena.
This matchup transcended the typical basketball games we regularly cover. Raw talent and pure intensity set this contest apart. These two programs put their basketball stars on full display this Friday night, and their fierce competition marked what could become a fierce I-75 rivalry.
OLSM Falls Short in High School Basketball Rankings After Narrow Loss to The Villages
Game-Changing Moments
The matchup was a roller coaster ride with OLSM going up by double digits, only to see the lead whittled away by fouls and 3-point shooting. One big question was answered, who will step up when star forward Trey McKenney doesn’t have his best game? The answer came in the performance of senior guard Sharrod Barnes. In a game when the OLSM style of aggressive defensive play seemed to keep them in the penalty situation, Barnes found a way to make things happen. While Trey McKenny struggled to muster 11 points, Barnes went on to have his best game of this young season with 24 points, 3 rebounds, 2 assists, and 3 steals. The game-winning shot highlighted the performance that left only 2 seconds on the clock. St. Johns got solid performances from 6’6 junior Race Kowalczyk, 6’3 senior guard Jayden Jones, and 6’6 junior Coy Hamic.
The OLSM and Toledo St. John Jesuit basketball contest showcased why high school basketball captivates audiences.
McKenney scored 11 points against a tough defense, but senior Sharrod Barnes’s play under pressure showed why he ranks among the state’s highly regarded talents.
Beyond the final score, a compelling rivalry emerged between these teams. Their shared Catholic High School League membership reflects more than competition – it represents excellence, competitive spirit, and steadfast dedication.
The game reinforced basketball’s appeal through clutch free throws, defensive stands, and last-second drama. Both teams proved they belonged at the top of their class. Their one-point margin will resonate in both schools and create anticipation for future matchups between these budding rivals. OLSM’s next game will be against U of D High School in the first Catholic League match-up of the year on December 13th.
